ClockPlayEmailInstagramLinkSMSTwitterYouTubeWhatsAppXSearchClockRight ArrowArrow DownCaret downCaret upCaret leftCaret rightHamburger MenuPop OutThumbs upThumbs up buySpeechAudio onReplayPlusMinusSad smiley faceNo resultsSwapMoreYour grocery bagSuccessShop Tasty MerchYour Cart (empty)Your CartFacebookPinterestEmailPrintSmsTwitterWhatsappCommentTips HighlightsRed XGreen Check
Skip to Content

As A Die-Hard Costco Fan, These Are The 34 Fall Food Items I'll Be Picking Up ASAP During My Next Shopping Trip

Light a candle, turn on the oven, and finally kick off cozy season.

Finally ready to embrace all things fall? Download the free Tasty app to browse and save thousands of recipes for cozy season.

It’s that stretch of the year when the cart somehow steers toward pumpkin, apple, and anything that smells like cinnamon.

I pulled together the Costco items that actually make chilly nights easier: bakery ringers you can slice and freeze, heat-and-eat chili and soup, a tear-apart garlic bread made for dunking, and pantry helpers that turn a regular weeknight into something warm and intentional.

Costco Wholesale storefront with large sign, set against a clear sky
Bing-jhen Hong / Getty Images

You’ll also see the fun stuff that makes home feel special right now, like espresso and coffee kits for DIY lattes, ginger beer for quick fall mocktails during weekend hangouts, and a warming tray so dips and chili stay perfect while everyone grazes. And yes, the pumpkin pie soft-serve “flurry” hack is here because it’s too good not to share.

Pumpkin pies in plastic containers stacked on a store shelf. Price above: $5.99 each for a 58 oz pie
Sydney Martin

1. Pumpkin Streusel Muffins

Pumpkin streusel muffins in clear packaging, labeled with ingredients and nutritional information
Sydney Martin

Soft, bakery-big, and perfect when warmed for 10 seconds. Split and butter for an at-home coffee shop moment.

Price: $6.99

2. Catalina Crunch Cinnamon Toast Cereal

Person holding a bag of Catalina Crunch protein cereal, cinnamon toast flavor, in a store. Price tag above reads $12.69
Sydney Martin

Crispy, cinnamon-warm cereal that leans toward fall even in a parfait. Layer with Greek yogurt and apples for a fast breakfast.

Price: $12.69

3. Pumpkin Pie

Pumpkin pie in a clear plastic container with a price label on top, displayed on a metal shelf
Sydney Martin

Back and still gigantic, it’s the easy dessert that basically hosts itself. Pro move: Crumble a slice into the food-court vanilla soft serve for a DIY pumpkin-pie “flurry.”

Price: $5.99

4. Girl Scouts Coconut Caramel Granola Clusters

Bag of Girl Scouts Coconut Caramel Granola Clusters on display, featuring crunchy granola baked with toasted coconut and caramel
Sydney Martin

All the vibes of the cookie you love — in snackable clusters. Sprinkle on ice cream or pack for soccer sidelines.

Price: $10.99

5. Pumpkin Cheesecake with Whipped Topping

Pumpkin cheesecake with whipped topping and crumb garnish on display in a store container
Sydney Martin

Dense, rich, and a small-slice-goes-far situation. Freeze a few wedges for late-night forkfuls when the house is finally quiet.

Price: $21.99

6. Caramel Apple Strudel Bites

Plastic containers filled with bite-sized apple strudels, labeled with nutritional information
Sydney Martin

Flaky pockets that taste like a quick trip to the orchard. Add vanilla ice cream and call it dessert for a crowd.

Price: $6.99

7. Cranberry Walnut Loaf

Bagged cranberry walnut loaf displaying Kirkland Signature label
Sydney Martin

Toasts up beautifully with salted butter. Also, it's elite for turkey and brie sandwiches for lunch.

Price: $8.99

8. Miss Jones Pumpkin Bread & Muffin Mix

Pumpkin bread and muffin mix box from Miss Jones Baking Co., includes bread mix, cream cheese icing, and cinnamon streusel topping
Sydney Martin

Pumpkin spice that isn’t excessively sweet. Stir in dark chocolate or pecans, and the whole house will smell like fall in under an hour.

Price: $8.99

9. Kodiak Nuts & Seeds Oatmeal Variety Pack

Shelf sign displaying: Kodiak Oatmeal Nuts & Seeds, 20/1.94 oz, price per ounce $4.10, sell price $15.89
Sydney Martin

Hearty cups that actually feel like a meal on cold school mornings. Add sliced apple and a drizzle of peanut butter, and call it done.

Price: $15.89

10. Nature’s Path Pumpkin Seed & Flax Granola

Packages of Pumpkin Seed + Flax Granola are stacked on a warehouse shelf, priced at $8.99
Sydney Martin

Crunchy without the sticky sugar bomb. Sprinkle over yogurt with sliced apples, or use as a quick crumble topping.

Price: $8.99

11. Bake Believe Dark Chocolate Baking Chips

Bag of Bake Believe Dark Chocolate Baking Chips with zero sugar
Sydney Martin

Deep chocolate flavor without over-sweet bakes. Melt with a little coconut oil for a drizzle over pumpkin bread.

Price: $15.99

12. Bonne Maman Four Fruits Preserves

A hand holds a jar of Bonne Maman Four Fruits Preserves in a store, with a shelf full of jars and a price tag of $10.99 visible
Sydney Martin

Swirl into oatmeal, glaze a brie for a quick app, or spoon over yogurt with granola.

Price: $10.99

13. Rao’s Eggplant Parmesan

Box of Rao's Eggplant Parmesan featuring breaded eggplant slices in marinara topped with Italian cheeses
Sydney Martin

Bubbly, cheesy comfort that bakes while you set the table. Add garlic bread and a bagged salad, and consider dinner handled.

Price: $11.79

14. Beef Chili

Sydney Martin

Hearty, ready, and ideal for football Sundays. Ladle over baked potatoes or serve with cornbread and shredded cheddar.

Price: $4.29/lb (about $16.99)

15. Rotisserie Chicken Noodle Soup

Containers of chicken noodle soup with nutrition labels displayed on a store shelf
Sydney Martin

Classic and soothing for the first cold of the season. A squeeze of lemon at the end perks it right up.

Price: $3.99/lb (about $16.16)

16. Graza Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Graza extra virgin olive oil bottles with yellow labels displayed on a store shelf, priced at $12.99
Sydney Martin

Mellow, but bright, Graza Olive Oil is roasting-season fuel. Drizzle on soups and roasted squash for a glossy finish.

Price: $12.99

17. Shepherd’s Pie

Packaged shepherd's pie with mashed potato topping, sprinkled with herbs. Label includes product details and pricing
Sydney Martin

Savory filling under a mashed-potato blanket that crisps on top. Let it rest for 10 minutes so your scoops hold together.

Price: $4.29/lb (about $24.50)

18. Ivar’s Loaded Baked Potato Soup

Ivar's Loaded Baked Potato Soup box on a store shelf. Sign above shows price as $9.99 for 2/24 oz. Containers are ready to heat, serve, and gluten-free
Sydney Martin

Ultra-creamy with bacon-cheddar vibes. Top with chives and extra cheese, and you’re done.

Price: $9.99

19. Tipiak Pull-Apart Garlic & Herb Cheese Bread

Garlic & herb cheese bread boxes on a store shelf, priced at $13.99 each
Sydney Martin

Bake until golden and let everyone tear into it at the table. Pairs with every soup on this list.

Price: $13.99

20. Kewpie Deep Roasted Sesame Dressing & Marinade

Person holding a bottle of Kewpie Deep-Roasted Sesame Dressing & Marinade in a store
Sydney Martin

Toasty, creamy sesame that makes warm grain bowls and slaws taste restaurant-level. Also, a fast marinade for sheet-pan chicken thighs.

Price: $7.99

21. Kirkland Signature Butter Toffee Cashews

Bag of Kirkland Signature Butter Toffee Cashews displayed in a store
Sydney Martin

Sweet-salty crunch that lives on the coffee table all season. Also excellent chopped over apple crisp or vanilla ice cream.

Price: $9.89

22. Ninja Luxe Café Signature Series

Ninja coffee machine display in a store, featuring various brewing modes and a dual frothing system with accompanying accessories
Sydney Martin

Hot or iced, frothy or simple, this makes your fall drink order happen in pajamas. Pair with pumpkin muffins and you’ve got a whole vibe.

Price: $529.99

23. Ghirardelli Jack-O’-Lanterns Chocolate Assortment

Ghirardelli limited edition chocolate assortment pack featuring pumpkin-shaped chocolates in caramel apple, caramel, and milk chocolate flavors
Sydney Martin

A very respectable candy-bowl upgrade. The caramel apple flavor keeps it seasonal without getting gimmicky.

Price: $12.99

24. Tostitos Salsa Verde Tortilla Chips

Bag of Tostitos Salsa Verde tortilla chips on a store shelf, showing chip and salsa images on the package
Sydney Martin

Tangy, crisp, and elite with chili or taco soup. Also, a quick base for sheet-pan nachos on game days.

Price: $6.49

25. Grab & Go Sweet & Salty Snack Box

Store shelf with orange boxes labeled "Grab & Go Sweet & Salty Pack," featuring snacks like SkinnyPop and Reese's. Price: $14.99
Sydney Martin

A little sweet, a little salty, zero portioning from you. Perfect for game days, car pools, and lunchbox backups.

Price: $14.99

26. Reese’s Peanut Butter Pumpkins

A pack of Reese's Peanut Butter Pumpkins with a Halloween-themed design
Sydney Martin

Everyone knows the peanut-to-chocolate ratio in the holiday shapes is perfection. Hide an extra bag for “movie night.”

Price: $14.74

27. KitKat “Halloween Lovers” Assortment

Bag of KitKat candy with various themed wrappers, including witch's brew and ghost popcorn flavors, displayed on a shelf
Sydney Martin

Marshmallow “Witch's Brew,” cinnamon-toast “Ghost Toast,” plus the classics — your candy bowl just went themed without trying. Great for movie nights and trick-or-treat trades.

Price: $14.39

28. Nespresso Vertuo Next Coffee Kit

Nespresso Vertuo Next Barista Coffee Kit in box with 32 coffee pods and $20 coffee voucher. Includes coffee machine and milk frother
Sydney Martin

Dial in your at-home fall lattes without the drive-thru line. Test pods, add your favorite creamer or syrup, and you’ve got a daily PSL situation.

Price: $139.99

29. Martinelli’s Sparkling Cider

Store display of Martinelli's Sparkling Cider, a 4-pack priced at $11.79, labeled as 100% juice, U.S. grown, and alcohol-free
Sydney Martin

Festive without alcohol for Sunday roasts and kid toasts. Keep a few bottles cold for impromptu guests.

Price: $11.79

30. General Mills Halloween Mini Variety Pack

Halloween-themed assorted fruit snacks pack with Gushers, Fruit by the Foot, and Fruit Roll-Ups. Contains 90 mini pouches
Sydney Martin

Lunchbox-friendly fruit snacks that make October feel festive. Also great for trunk-or-treat.

Price: $12.99

31. Starbucks Salted Caramel Macchiato Creamer

Person holding a Starbucks caramel macchiato creamer bottle in a store aisle
Sydney Martin

Turns plain coffee into a cozy treat. A splash in some hot cocoa is very fun on movie nights.

Price: $7.99

32. Fever-Tree Ginger Beer

Fever-Tree Premium Ginger Beer packs stacked on a supermarket shelf, priced at $15.99 for a 12-pack
Sydney Martin

Real ginger bite that anchors the best fall mocktails. Mix with apple cider and a squeeze of lime for easy holiday sippers.

Price: $15.99

33. Starbucks Seasons Cheer Whole Bean Coffee

A hand holds a bag of Starbucks Season's Cheer Blend coffee, noting cocoa and dried fruit flavors. Other bags are stacked behind it
Sydney Martin

Holiday-leaning beans that make the kitchen smell the way a knit blanket feels. Grind fresh and serve with pumpkin muffins.

Price: $16.99

34. Chefman Family-Sized Glass Top Warming Tray

Boxes of Chefman family-sized glass top warming trays stacked in a store aisle. Packaging shows three trays with different dishes inside
Sydney Martin

Set it to low and keep dips, meatballs, and mashed potatoes warm without babysitting the stove. It’s the secret weapon for chili bars and Friendsgiving apps.

Price: $49.99

That’s my fall cart. What did I miss? Drop your seasonal MVP (and your warehouse price) in the comments below.

For cozy recipes that scream fall, download the free Tasty app — no subscription required.

Close-up of a slice of apple pie topped with white icing drizzle, highlighting layers of apple filling and flaky crust
Tasty

Trending Recipes

Trending Recipes

More Tasty Guides

More Tasty Guides

    See all